The Cask of Amontillado” and “A Rose for Emily”

“The Cask of Amontillado” and “A Rose for Emily” have many

important similarities as well as many differences. While both stories

are gothic horror tales that end in murder. “The Cask of Amontillado”

implies foul play from the very beginning while “A Rose for Emily”

surprises us with the grotesque details at the end of the story.

Edgar Allan Poe uses vivid images to make the horrific

situation very realistic to reader. Monstresor must have revenge

without getting caught otherwise there will be no pleasure in it.

While Fortunato does not suspect Montresor wishes him harm, it is

ironic that what Fortunato cherishes most, his knowledge of fine wine,

Is what ultimately leads to his own demise.

Unlike Montresor, Rose did not fit the likely stereotype of a

vengeful killer. She is perceived as desperately trying to play the part

of a “southern lady” while the rest of the town considers her a freaky

spinster. ...